POSCO Judgment of National Green Tribunal

 sagarmedia on March 31, 2012 On March 30, 2012, the National Green Tribunal held in Prafulla Samantra and Anr. vs Union of India and Ors. that the 31.1.2011 final order of the Environment Ministry – permitting the POSCO project to go ahead with certain conditions – should be suspended until a full review of the project can be undertaken (by specialists with fresh terms of reference). The NGT Bench consisted of Justice C.V. Ramulu, Judicial Member, and Dr. Devendra Kumar Agarwal, Expert Member. The tribunal has observed that, “A close scrutiny of the entire scheme … reveals that a project of this magnitude particularly in partnership with a foreign country has been dealt with casually, without there being any comprehensive scientific data regarding the possible environmental impacts. No meticulous scientific study was made on each and every aspect of the matter leaving lingering and threatening environmental and ecological doubts un-answered.” (para 7, page 22) It has also seriously questioned the appointment of Ms. Meena Gupta as the chairperson of the review committee which was set up by the MoEF in 2010. The judgement states that Ms. Gupta’s appointment was “definitely hit by personal / official / departmental bias, in other words, she supported the decision made by her earlier. This is in gross violation of principles of natural justice.” (para 6.9 page 22) Key Directions of the Green Tribunal The Tribunal has directed a “fresh review of the Project” (para 8.1) that has to look at the problems noted in this judgment as well as the majority and minority reports of the earlier Enquiry Committee (see list of dates), etc. In particular it has to look at: Land and infrastructure: The clearance was given for a 4 million tonnes per annum (MTPA) steel plant, but the land, water etc. were allocated for a 12 MTPA project (which has been POSCO’s stated plan). The judgment directs MoEF to “consider optimizing the total land requirement for 4 MTPA steel plant proportionately.”(para 8.5) Moreover, the impacts of other infrastructure for the plant have not been assessed at all, even though they were planned for a 12 MTPA plant. Issues that should have been done now, but which MoEF left for future studies: On several points highlighted by the review committee, the MoEF just said future studies should be done and ignored the issue. The Tribunal finds this deeply unsatisfactory, and notes the following among other issues: Water: The Tribunal said that “We are all aware that … the drinking water is becoming scarce commodity and at every level precaution needs to be taken for protecting the drinking water supply to human habitation and preventing from utilizing such water for industrial use … alternative water source for the present project, like creating/ constructing a small barrage or augmenting any other existing source at the cost of project proponent to avoid the utilizing the water meant for Cuttack city… could be examined.” (para 7.4, page 29) Pollution: The plant’s discharge was also left for future study by MoEF. The Tribunal says this is a “serious environmental concern.” (para 7.4, page 30) Impact on surrounding wetlands and mangroves, as well as cyclone risk: This was left for vague future studies without any time frame or modus operandi. In addition, the Ministry has to frame a policy to ensure large projects are assessed in full for a single clearance (rather than being allowed to get piecemeal clearances for each component, as in this case) and for their full capacity at the start (paras 8.7,8.9). It also has to do a strategic assessment of the ports in Orissa. (para 8.8) POSCO and the government sought to argue that the case cannot be filed as the original clearances were given in 2007 (and, incidentally, will expire in May/July this year). The Tribunal held that the 2011 order can still be looked at even if the 2007 ones cannot be; it therefore directed review and suspension of the 2011 order. POSCO and/or the government can appeal this decision in the Supreme Court. Meanwhile, MoEF has to constitute a review committee of subject specialists (para 8.3), define timelines for compliance with conditions (para 8.4), establish a committee for monitoring compliance with these conditions (para 8.4). No work can start on the project until the review process is over. The case was argued by Sr. Adv. Raj Punjwani, Adv. Ritwick Dutta and Adv. Rahul Choudhary for the petitioners. Key Events      June 2005: POSCO, Orissa government sign MoU for 12 million tonne steel plant, private port and captive iron ore mines. Protests begin in steel plant area and area is cordoned off by peaceful protesters.     May 2007: Environmental clearance for port granted by Environment Ministry, then under A. Raja.     July 2007: Environmental clearance for plant granted by Environment Ministry, then under PM. Secretary is Meena Gupta. Protests continue in the face of violent attacks and numerous arrests.     December 2009: Forest clearance granted for taking over forest land by Environment Ministry, then under Jairam Ramesh.     August 2010: Forest clearance suspended following complaints of violations of law, and Enquiry Committee constituted under Meena Gupta.     October 2010: Three member majority of enquiry committee gives report saying environmental and forest clearances illegal. Meena Gupta dissents, holds clearances legal but recommends additional study and time to ensure compliance.     January 31, 2011: Environment Ministry disregards both majority and minority reports, upholds environment and forest clearances, while prescribing some additional conditions (mostly consisting of additional studies to be done in future).     June 2011: Prafulla Samantray challenges final order in National Green Tribunal.     March 31, 2012: Green Tribunal judgment.  For further information: Prafulla Samantray, activist and petitioner in this case, 09437259005 Prashant Paikray, POSCO Pratirodh Sangram Samiti, 09437571547 Kanchi Kohli, activist, 9811903112, kanchikohli@gmail.com Shankar Gopalakrishnan, Campaign for Survival and Dignity, 9873657844, shankargopal@myfastmail.com

Sagar Media Inc_ The Events Organizer

Sagar Media Inc

http://sagarmediainc.wordpress.com/ Sagar Media Inc

http://nareshsagar.blogspot.in/

Sagar Media Inc

 

Sagar Media Inc, Chairman:
Vice President,Akhil Bhartiya Patarkar Manch:
Vice President, Delhi Chapter, The Newspaper Editor'Society:
Chairman:Enkay Sagar Holdings P Ltd:
Former Secretary,International Theosophical Society,Delhi Region:
The Editor,www.topix.com/in/agra/India

Sagar Media Inc - The Events Organizer, offer services in field
of seminars,conferences,social programmer, social, business events,with
logistic and without logistics.Knowledge Repository Digital Journalism a chapter of Enkaysagar
Holdings Pvt Ltd.Daily Seminars,Conferences Workshops in N Delhi is
stored as Knowledge Repository Digital Journalism.A branding,
promotional,product videos are the forte of our company and we have
branded more than 1370 Sagar News,views and reviews videos covering
wide range of sectors.Sagar Media Prepares daily the
Seminars,Conferences and Workshops

To:

nksagar_1@yahoo.com

Mar 21, 2012
Developing an Effective Internship Program - 2 Part Series April 20 & 27, 2012 Webinar Writing Effective Online Job Descriptions June 22, 2012 Webinar 2012 North American Ag HR Roundtable August 7 - 9, 2012 Springdale, Arkansas Contact Information: 800.929.8975 877.438.5729 Email us	AgCareers.com Releases 2011 Job Analysis Report An analysis of 2011 trends from AgCareers.com yields a positive outlook for the agriculture industry. Agriculture companies are anticipating gains, rewarding employees and looking to fill job openings with qualified talent. AgCareers.com recently published the 2011 U.S. Agribusiness Job Report and the 2011 Canadian Agribusiness Job Report and found that job postings were up significantly from the previous year, demonstrating the strength of the agriculture industry. Jobs posted ranged in industry type, such as agronomy, crop protection/chemicals, biotechnology, dairy, equipment/machinery, etc., which appeal to a large audience of candidates. Posted jobs were from a wide variety of career types, from manager to technician. AgCareers.com attracts a wide range of candidates to the site. Nearly half of all candidates had more than five years of experience and the majority had a bachelor's degree or higher. Below are a few other highlights of the report: The number of jobs posted in North America grew by 18%; there were over 43,000 jobs posted by companies in the United States and Canada in 2011. Read More... Check out these AgCareers.com products!
MR of Sioux Falls, LLP MR of Sioux Falls, LLP has more than 19 years successfully recruiting in the agriculture industry throughout the country (including fertilizer, chemicals, seed, grain, feed and nutrition). View MR of Sioux Falls, LLP Jobs   Nutreco Nutreco Canada offers world-class animal nutrition feeding programs and branded pet food products to its customers. View Nutreco Jobs   PIC PIC is the international leader in providing genetically superior pig breeding stock and technical support for maximizing genetic potential to the global pork chain. View PIC Jobs   The Climate Corporation The Climate Corporation helps people and businesses adapt to climate change. They are dedicated to making a difference in the lives of their customers around the globe. View The Climate Corporation Jobs	Professional Services Senior Associate SureHarvest Soquel, California, West United States, USA Product Marketing Manager BASF, The Chemical Company Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, South United States, USA Production Supervisor Holden Farms Northfield, Minnesota, Mid-West United States, USA Legal Assistant Muscatine Foods Corporation Muscatine, Iowa, Mid-West United States, USA Route Sales Representative Innovative Dairy Solutions Mid-Atlantic United States, USA Manager - Precision Agriculture Business Agri-Trend Integrated Solutions MS, TN, KY, IN, South United States, USA International Manufacturing Engineer Valmont Industries Valley, Nebraska, Mid-West United States, USA Maintenance Mechanic Peri & Sons Farms Yerington, Nevada, West United States USA Program Development Sales Representative - Dairy MWI Veterinary Supply WA-OR-N CA; Central CA; WI Service Technician Johnson Equipment Company Whiteville, North Carolina, South United States, USA Agronomist McCain Foods USA, Inc. Idaho, West United States, USA Product Development Manager Arcadia Biosciences Davis, California, West United States, USA ...more USA jobs Director of Produce Relations and Communication BC Dairy Association Burnaby, British Columbia, Western Canada, Canada Product Support Specialist Westgen Langley, British Columbia, Western Canada, Canada Chief Financial Officer Andrukow Group Camrose, Alberta, Western Canada, Canada Territory Sales Manager - Medicine Hat Bayer CropScience Medicine Hat, Alberta, Western Canada, Canada Regional Manager - Alberta ICMS, Inc. Fort Saskatchewan, Alberta, Western Canada, Canada Grain Marketing Rep Great Sandhills Terminal Leader, Saskatchewan, Prairies Canada, Canada Agro Sales Specialist Federated Co-operatives Limited Thorhild, Manitoba, Prairies Canada, Canada Plant Manager - Elva, MB (Ref No: 11381809) Cargill, Inc Elva, Manitoba, Prairies Canada, Canada Director of Business Development Vineland Research and Innovation Centre Vineland Station, Ontario, Central Canada, Canada Biogas Systems Supervisor Grober Group of Companies Cambridge, Ontario, Central Canada, Canada Field Service Representative Maternity Leave (Contract) Chicken Farmers of Ontario Eastern Ontario, Ontario, Central Canada, Canada Grain Marketing Advisor Southwest Ag Partners Chatham, Ontario, Central Canada, Canada ...more Canada jobs
Please email agcareers@agcareers.com for newsletter suggestions, comments or concerns.

EKN’s guarantee is there to help.

21 March 2012: New Delhi:Eminent speakers and the board of directors of EKN organized today a seminar at The Swedish Chamber of Commerce India Swedish Trade Council,New Delhi.

EKN is a government agency that supports Swedish exports and the internationalisation of Swedish industry. This we do by offering
exporting companies and banks guarantees for payment and financing, together with advice on business structure and risk management. Our services provide an extra level of confidence,increased competitiveness and more opportunities for successful export transactions.

 Ms. Karin Apelman, the Director General and Head of EKN,  present how EKN can insure Swedish companies in India against the risk of non-payment in export transactions, thereby enabling them to conduct more secure export transactions. 

Director General and Head of EKN and  the Swedish Export Credits Guarantee Board director presented their case study as to how EKN can insure Swedish companies in India against the risk of non-payment in export transactions, thereby enabling them to conduct more secure export transactions.
EKN is a governmental agency which provides companies, banks and financial institutions with state guarantees against losses incurred in export transactions and foreign investment. 

With the support from EKN, Swedish companies and financing banks can offer their customers attractive financial terms and conditions. Long-term credits, high-risk markets, complex transactions, small transactions when there is no cover on the commercial insurance market, EKN’s guarantee is  to help MSME and private sector.

 N K Sagar,

Vol. 8 Week 11 | 14 March 2012     HIGHLIGHT Upcoming workshop in Hong Kong: Next Level CSR-Shaping a New Future for your Organisation Workshop The Next Level CSR workshop will focus on harnessing your organisation’s CSR energy in creating new initiatives that are embraced by internal and external stakeholders. Check out more details from the links below. Next Level CSR-Shaping a New Future for your Organisation Workshop (29 March 2012) Corporate Governance, Fair Operating Practices and Government Relations The next module of the new Professional Master’s in CSR offered by CSR Asia in collaboration with the Asian Institute of Technology (AIT), Thailand, will be delivered in Bangkok over four intensive days from Friday 23rd to Monday 26th March, 2012. The module, which can be taken as an individual ‘stand-alone’ course, will focus on the good corporate governance that is the foundation of good CSR. Key corporate governance challenges in the region will be considered including the power of shareholders, government relations, competition, Board diversity, socially responsible investment and bribery and corruption. Interested applicants can visit www.csrcenter.ait.asia or email csrcenter@ait.asia for further details. ARTICLES Next level CSR I started working in Corporate Social Responsibility based on the conviction that it can make a difference in the world. Two years ago I moved to Hong Kong and my drive started to shrink slowly as I felt sustainability and CSR are seen differently... Read more Tackling Food Waste A few weeks ago, I attended an event organised by the British Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong on the topic of ‘Reduce, Reuse and Recycle’. The event invited speakers from business, Government and NGOs to share their approach ... Read more “Temporary employment” in China The topic of labour shortages comes up every year in China after the Lunar New Year break. These days, when you mention migrant workers at this time of years the terms “shortage” and “rising wages” are sure to be included. A typical ... Read more New Mandatory Reporting Laws on Energy and Waste in Singapore Singapore has made a noteworthy step in the area of mandatory corporate energy and greenhouse gas emissions measurement and simplification of energy regulation. Two new laws, one on energy and the other on waste, will come into ... Read more NEWS Malaysia: Safety under threat: Bekok Dam Farming related chemicals, including fertilisers and diesel-powered machinery, ... Read more Commercial Plant to Start Producing Hydrogen from Woody Biomass in April Idex Eco Energy Co., a wholly owned subsidiary of Japanese... Read more This week’s roundup includes stories about AmCham CSR Awards, Guangdong’s emission reduction efforts, water resources in Beijing ... Read more CSR Wednesday - "The case for diversity in the boadroom" March 14, 2012 Malaysia Training - "CSR Essentials" March 27, 2012 Hong Kong Training - "Reporting and Communications" April 17, 2012 Malaysia Training - "Investing for Impact: Tools and Approaches for Community Investment" May 15, 2012 Hong Kong Training - "Reporting and Communications " June 5, 2012 Singapore CSR Asia Summit 2012 September 18-19, 2012 Hong Kong Published by: Disclaimer: Opinions reflected in the articles are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of CSR Asia. Copyright © 2011, CSR Asia. All rights reserved Join us now on LinkedIn

Forward email